Weight Watchers v. Calorie Counting

Because I have too much time on my hands right now, I am using both Weight Watchers and my favorite calorie counting app, Tap&Track, to record what I am eating. I am pitting them against each other and judging them in the following areas:

1) Ease of Entering in restaurant foods
2) Cost (Tap&Track wins this, it is 3.99 for a lifetime, WW is about18 bucks a month)
3) Ease of entering in specialized foods and recipes
4) Accuracy
5) Usefulness of nutritional information available from app/website
6) Helpfulness of community forums/posts

I think this will be an interesting project, because most reviews concentrate on whether the darned thing makes you lose weight.  I think this is important, but the ability to use and stick to the tracking system is what makes the difference in long term success. If you lose weight, but get annoyed at having to enter your information and give up tracking, you are way more likely to gain the weight back than if you find the process easy and unobtrusive.

Also, I am interested to really delve into the support options on Weight Watchers. These features and the nutritional information are really what make the program cost more, so my question is: is  all of that extra stuff worth it?